Equality and difference: persisting historical themes in health and alcohol policies affecting Indigenous Australians
Journal of Epidemiology and Community Health 2007;61:759-763;
Disseminating national health and alcohol policies to Aboriginal
and Torres Strait Islander people in Australia has been a challenging
task for governments and public servants.
This has been for
a number of reasons, including the enduring (negative) legacy
of past "Aboriginal affairs" policies, the fact that Indigenous
health programmes and alcohol programmes have been treated separately
since the 1970s, and a more recent context in which the recognition
of cultural difference was privileged.
Confronted with the politics
of difference, health departments were slow to examine avenues
through which best practice advice emanating from WHO, and alcohol
policies such as harm minimisation and early identification
and treatment in primary health care, could be communicated
in culturally recognisable ways to independent Indigenous services.
In addition, there was hostility towards harm minimisation policies
from Indigenous service providers, and Indigenous treatment
programmes remained largely committed to abstinence-oriented
modalities and the disease model of alcoholism, despite moves
away from these approaches in the mainstream.
However, genuinely
innovative acute interventions and environmental controls over
alcohol have been developed by Indigenous community-based organisations,
approaches that are reinforced by international policy research
evidence.
Read Full AbstractReprint Request E-Mail: Maggie.brady@anu.edu.au
___________________________________________________________________________